Happy hours... In school!
I just got an invite for a student-faculty beer party in my department. Apparently, this is going to happen the first friday of every month. Wow! Leaving the beer factor alone, whats making me cheer is the idea that students and faculty can get together for an informal afternoon and have a good time. I don't think this would have ever been heard of in the home country. I am not looking to ruffle any sensitive feathers here. I hate people picking on India too. But I have to say this. The level of informality the phirangs achieve in the student-teacher relationship is phenomenal.
I was first shocked at students eating and drinking in class. I was wondering how the professor does not find it offensive. And the students, how could they eat and pay attention at the same time? I slowly got used to the idea, and now, I eat too. I find that I can pay attention better if I am not hungry and thinking about what I will eat after class. Maybe the guy who is teaching has the same thought.
Its not just the food factor ( although so far, all I have written seems purely alimentary). Its just the comfort level. I think that arises out of the fact that these guys ( my current teachers) don't need us to think they are superior to us. They may be or they may not be. Very often, they are. Teachers in India wewre superior to us too. Only, they made sure we knew it.
I may have made too many generalizations so far. But largely, I think I am right. I have thought about this a good deal. The individual systems seem to be traditionally established in India and the USA. I don't know much about cultural roots in the USA but I have wondered why the system is the way it is,in India. Are we experiencing the legacy of the gurukula? Serving the teacher and being obsequious? But surely, that is only our interpretation of it. If the teacher and all his students lived and travelled together, they surely would have developed intimacy and informality between them?Maybe that is what the pupils learn better and not the service factor.
Too much read into a beer party invitation? Maybe. But think about it. Beer may not be socially appropriate in India for a teacher-student party. I will therefore not elaborate on the number of awe-inspiring Medical College professors who have been seen dancing in advanced stages of intoxication during conferences. But have you heard of any department getting together with its students for, say, orange juice, every week?
I have had a great time in college in Bangalore and I am having a great time here. The only difference is, now I dont need to hide when a professor passes by beacuse I bunked the previous class. I can say "Hi, I went to Niagara falls last week. Can I clarify a point which you made last class?" And chances are, the point will be clarified. They even have alternate dates if you cant make it to class to a test. No questions asked.
The margin for error is simply great. It leads to a huge comfort level and their economy is not exactly suffering because of it. So, what do you say to saturday afternoon bajji parties in BMC?
PS: Looking to get bombarded with indignant patriotic comments. Dont disappoint me!!
7 Comments:
By and large yes, that is what I've experienced most of my student life. Teachers are supposed to be larger than life figures and students are expected to respect them no matter what. This aspect reached unbelievable levels during engineering. A student was detained for an year just because he ignored/forgot to wish his prof in hallway. But things changed drastically during my higher studies. The level of comfort with teachers at IIT was simply amazing. The interaction was always informal, and we would discuss cricket as frequently as course material. Also there the attitude was that teachers were learning along with us. Just by not carrying halo around them those professors inspired us to work harder. And yes, we met regularly (if not once a week, time was an issue you see :)) for chai session. God knows how much I miss those days :(.
12:32 PM
And yeah forgot to add. During masters, admission to my department was thru written test and interviews apart from GATE. This entire process was organized by senior students. We would strive to come up with the toughest possible question paper for the written test. And every year we would have a bet with department head about the maximum score. What was at stake ?. Whisky :). And I've been a part of booze treat with profs as well. But again, I guess this is just an isolated case.
- ASJ
12:45 PM
in engineering a lecturer is supposed to take up some 50 classes every semester,out of which students bunk 10 and the lecturer bunks another 10,at times we end up bearing their gibberish even without knowing their names.any kind of personal relation is a far fetched thing.oh well in bmc,may be it can.
4:30 PM
beer reminds me.. you left without buying me beer :-(
6:24 PM
This comment has been removed by the author.
8:47 PM
I have come across a few teachers(most of them have studied abroad) trying to inculcate this atmosphere in IIM. Ill tell u two reasons why it doesn't seem to be working out.
1) The teacher to student ratio is small even in premier institutes. They have a set of faculty who exclusively do research and never get to see students.
2)From my experience 'Networking' of any kind always draws attention in India. In Europe it is common to chat with the prof abt travel, infact anything. In the highly competitive atmosphere at home........it is always seen as 'one upmanship'.........soon profs also realize this and stop interacting!....
Neways Im always game for a cup of hot coffee..........One of my profs had discussed his prev gf's with us:-)...........Call that learning from experience!!
9:04 PM
Well, I am seeing the same here too.
-Every Friday after the weekly technical seminar, the entire group of profs, students, invited speakers (around 30 people) amble out of the building to continue with the symposium part of the day. (Hint: Look up "symposium").
-The project groups have potlucks, and picnics every semester.
-Its become warmer now, so the prof suggests we could hold the next class beside the lake.
I like these cheerful concepts..:)
3:00 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home